-------------------------------------------------------------------------
		   Readings in Database Systems

			     Review Form

Title of Paper:

Authors:

Reviewer Team (Name, Student Ids):

Date Review Completed:

Comments to Authors (Specific suggestions for improvements):


---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Relevance to Databases (check one):
	very low _____ low _____ marginal _____ high _____ very high _____

Significance of Contribution:
	very low _____ low _____ marginal _____ high _____ very high _____

Readability and Organization:
	very poor ____ poor ____ marginal _____ good _____ very good _____

Length (Relative to the useful contents of the paper):
	too long _____     too short _____      just right _____

Fusion of Theory and Practice:
	inadequate _____   marginal _____	adequate   _____

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Overall Recommendation:

	Poor _____       Fair  _____    Good _____    Very Good _____	        

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Merits Class Presentation (no or yes):

	1. Originality?  high_____    medium _____  low _____  none _____

	2. Does the paper open up a new and relevant area of research
		and development?
	
		yes _____	no _____
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Confidential Notes to Instrucor: